Beyond Open Rates: Leveraging Email Metrics for Restaurant Success

“The real value of metrics lies not in the numbers themselves, but in the insights they provide.” 

– Annette Franz, Customer Experience Strategist

Introduction

In today’s technological era, restaurants must use every advantage they can get to remain competitive. Email marketing works well for reaching and engaging target audiences. But it’s not enough to just blast out emails to everyone. To truly drive success, restaurants must also be able to measure and analyze the performance of their email campaigns. This is where email metrics come into play.

Understanding what is and isn’t working in your email marketing is made much easier with the information provided by email metrics. By analyzing metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates, restaurants can fine-tune their email marketing strategies and drive better results.

In this article, we’ll explore the importance of leveraging email metrics for restaurant success. We’ll examine the benefits of this method, how to implement it yourself, and a popular restaurant chain that has already adopted it.

What is an Email Metric?

Email metrics are measurements of email performance that allow businesses to gauge how their email marketing campaigns are performing. Organizations may improve the efficacy of their email marketing initiatives by keeping tabs on the aforementioned KPIs and acting accordingly. In the restaurant industry, email metrics can be particularly helpful in driving customer engagement, loyalty, and retention.

Email Metrics Key Elements

An email metric consists of numerous interrelated parts, including:

• Open rate: The open rate is the fraction of people who actually opened an email. A higher open rate generally indicates that the subject line and sender name were effective at grabbing the recipient’s attention.

• Click-through rate (CTR): CTR is the proportion of email recipients who actually clicked on a link within the message. A higher CTR indicates that the email content and call-to-action were effective at engaging the recipient and driving them to take action.

• Conversion rate: After clicking on a link in an email, the conversion rate is the percentage of readers that complete the desired activity such as buying something or filling out a form.

• Bounce rate: This metric measures the percentage of emails that were not successfully delivered to recipients. A high bounce rate can be a sign of issues with email lists or deliverability.

• Unsubscribe rate: This metric measures the percentage of recipients who opted out of receiving future emails. A high unsubscribe rate can indicate issues with email content or frequency.

Role of an Email Metric to Measure Restaurant Success

The success of an eatery’s email marketing initiatives relies heavily on the data collected from the recipients’ inboxes. Restaurants may learn how their email campaigns are performing in terms of generating sales and consumer interaction by monitoring indicators such as the percentage of emails opened, clicked on, and converted.

If a restaurant’s email has a high open rate but a poor click-through rate, it may mean the content isn’t compelling or the call to action is unclear. A high CTR without a commensurate CVR may be an indication that the restaurant’s landing page is not fully optimized for conversions.

By using email metrics to identify areas for improvement, restaurants can refine their email marketing strategies and drive better results. By tracking metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates, restaurants can make data-driven decisions to optimize their email campaigns for better performance and improved customer engagement, loyalty, and retention.

Top Email Key Metrics Tools for Restaurants

There are many tools and apps available to help restaurants track email metrics and analytics. Here are some of the best tools and apps that restaurants can use for key metrics and analytics of email marketing.

1. Mailchimp

Mailchimp is a well-known email marketing solution that has comprehensive reporting and analytics capabilities. With Mailchimp, restaurants can track key metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and revenue generated from email campaigns. The tool also offers A/B testing and segmentation features to help restaurants optimize their email campaigns for better performance.

2. Constant Contact

Constant Contact is another popular email marketing tool that offers comprehensive analytics and reporting features. With Constant Contact, restaurants can track key metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and bounce rates. The tool also offers segmentation features to help restaurants target specific groups of customers with personalized content.

3. Google Analytics

Tracking website traffic and conversion rates has never been easier than using Google Analytics. Email marketing campaigns can be monitored for their impact on website traffic and income by connecting Google Analytics with your email marketing software. Google Analytics also offers segmentation features to help you identify which email campaigns are driving the most engagement and revenue.

4. Litmus

Litmus is a tool that helps restaurants optimize their email campaigns for different email clients and devices. The tool offers analytics and reporting features to help restaurants track how their emails are performing across different platforms. By using Litmus, restaurants can ensure that their emails are optimized for maximum engagement and deliverability.

5. HubSpot

HubSpot is a comprehensive marketing automation platform that offers email marketing, analytics, and reporting features. With HubSpot, restaurants can track key metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and revenue generated from email campaigns. The tool also offers advanced segmentation and personalization features to help restaurants deliver targeted and relevant content to their customers.

Using the right tools and apps can help restaurants track key metrics and analytics of email marketing to drive greater engagement, loyalty, and revenue. The success of restaurants’ email marketing efforts may be tracked and evaluated with the help of software like MailChimp, Constant Contact, Google Analytics, Litmus, and HubSpot.

Case Study: Shake Shack

One popular restaurant brand that implements email marketing effectively to drive customer engagement and loyalty is Shake Shack. The burger chain uses email marketing to promote new menu items, offer exclusive deals to subscribers, and drive traffic to its restaurants.

Shake Shack’s email campaigns include personalized content based on customer preferences and past purchase history. For example, the chain sends personalized offers to customers based on their favorite menu items and location preferences. Shake Shack also uses email segmentation to target specific groups of customers with relevant messaging.

In addition to personalized content, Shake Shack’s email campaigns feature eye-catching visuals and compelling CTAs to encourage subscribers to take action. The company also regularly tests and optimizes its email campaigns to improve performance over time.

When it comes to using email to increase client loyalty and ultimately boost revenue, Shake Shack is a shining example. By offering personalized content, using segmentation to target specific groups of customers, and regularly testing and optimizing campaigns, Shake Shack has been able to build a strong email marketing program that drives engagement and loyalty.

Benefits of Leveraging Email Metrics for Restaurant Success

There are several benefits to leveraging email metrics for restaurant success:

• Improved engagement: By analyzing email metrics, restaurants can fine-tune their email campaigns to increase engagement with their customers.

• Increased sales: Effective email marketing can lead to increased sales, as customers are more likely to visit or order from a restaurant that they feel a connection with.

• Better customer relationships: Personalized and relevant email content can help build stronger relationships with customers, leading to increased loyalty and repeat business.

• Greater efficiency: By analyzing email metrics, restaurants can identify what’s working and what’s not, allowing them to focus their efforts on the most effective tactics.

• Competitive advantage: Restaurants that effectively leverage email metrics can gain a competitive advantage by staying ahead of the curve and providing their customers with a better overall experience.

According to a study by Campaign Monitor, segmented email campaigns have an open rate that is 14.32% higher than non-segmented campaigns. It has also been proven that the conversion rate for personalized emails is six times that of generic ones.

15 Best Email Metric Strategies to Measure Restaurant Success

1. Set Goals and KPIs

Before measuring email metrics, it’s important for restaurants to set clear goals and key performance indicators (KPIs) for their email marketing campaigns. This will allow restaurants to measure success against specific targets and make data-driven decisions to optimize their campaigns.

2. Segment Email Lists

Segmenting email lists based on customer behavior and preferences can improve email relevance and engagement, leading to better email metrics. By sending targeted messages to specific segments, restaurants can increase open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates.

3. Personalize Email Content

Personalizing email content with customer names, preferences, and past purchase history can increase email relevance and engagement. Personalized emails can lead to higher open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates.

4. Optimize Subject Lines

Subject lines are the first thing customers see when receiving an email, and can greatly impact open rates. Restaurants should optimize subject lines by using clear and concise language, incorporating personalization, and A/B testing to find the most effective language.

5. Use Clear and Compelling CTAs

Click-through and conversion rates can be increased with the use of appealing and specific calls to action (CTAs). Restaurants should use action-oriented language and make it clear what action customers should take.

6. Monitor Deliverability

Deliverability metrics, such as bounce rates and spam complaints, can impact email metrics and overall campaign success. Restaurants should regularly monitor deliverability and take steps to improve it, such as regularly cleaning email lists and improving email authentication.

7. Measure Engagement

Engagement metrics, such as time spent reading emails and email forwards, can provide valuable insights into customer behavior and preferences. Restaurants should measure engagement metrics and use them to refine email content and targeting strategies.

8. Track Revenue

Tracking revenue from email campaigns can provide a clear picture of their impact on the bottom line. Restaurants should track revenue generated from email campaigns and use it to measure the success of their email marketing efforts.

9. Analyze Email Metrics Regularly

Regularly analyzing email metrics can provide insights into what’s working and what’s not, allowing restaurants to refine their email marketing strategies and improve results over time.

10. A/B Test Email Campaigns

A/B testing can help restaurants optimize email campaigns for better performance. By testing different email elements, such as subject lines, CTAs, and email content, restaurants can identify the most effective strategies for their audience.

11. Monitor Competition

Monitoring email marketing efforts of competitors can provide valuable insights into industry trends and opportunities. Restaurants should regularly monitor their competitors’ email campaigns and use insights to refine their own email marketing strategies.

12. Optimize Email Design

Email design can greatly impact email metrics, with clear and visually appealing designs leading to better engagement. Restaurants should optimize email design for mobile devices, incorporate images and visuals, and use clear and concise language.

13. Use Data to Personalize Offers

Using data such as past purchases and customer preferences, restaurants can personalize offers in their email campaigns. Personalized offers can lead to higher engagement and revenue.

14. Monitor Email Frequency

Email frequency can impact email metrics and overall campaign success. Restaurants should monitor email frequency and ensure they are not overwhelming customers with too many emails.

15. Continuously Improve Email Marketing Strategies

Email marketing is an ongoing process that requires continuous improvement. Restaurants should regularly analyze email metrics, test new strategies, and refine their email marketing efforts to drive better results over time.

How to Choose the Right Email Key Metric 

Using email marketing, restaurants may increase customer participation, brand loyalty, and revenue. In order to analyze your email marketing activities, you must choose the right metrics to track. Here’s a guide on how to choose the right metric to use.

1. Identify Your Goals and Objectives

Before choosing metrics to track, it’s important to identify your goals and objectives. This will guide you in selecting the KPIs that matter most for your company. Click-through rates and conversion percentages, for instance, may be the most relevant metrics to monitor if you’re trying to boost online sales.

2. Look for Metrics That Align with Your Goals

Once you have identified your goals and objectives, look for email metrics that align with them. For example, if your goal is to drive more foot traffic to your restaurant, then open rates and click-through rates may be more important to track than conversion rates.

3. Choose Metrics That are Measurable and Actionable

Make sure that the metrics you choose are measurable and actionable. This means that you should be able to effectively track them and utilize the data to enhance your email advertising. For example, open rates and click-through rates are measurable and can be used to improve email subject lines and CTAs.

4. Consider Customer Engagement Metrics

Learn more about how your consumers are responding to your emails by analyzing metrics like open, click-through, and bounce rates. You can strengthen your interactions with customers and increase engagement by keeping tabs on these measures.

5. Track Revenue and ROI

Email marketing works if it boosts sales and ROI. Tracking revenue and ROI can help you determine the effectiveness of your email campaigns and make data-driven decisions to improve performance over time.

How to Adjust Email Marketing Strategy Based on Key Metric Results

The ability to fine-tune your email marketing approach in response to actual outcomes is a major perk of keeping tabs on relevant analytics. Here’s a guide on how to adjust your email marketing strategy in accordance to key metric results:

• Identify Areas for Improvement: Start by reviewing your email metrics to identify areas where your campaigns may be underperforming. For example, if your open rates are low, you may need to focus on improving your subject lines or send times.

• Set Goals for Improvement: Once you have identified areas for improvement, set specific goals for improvement. If your click-through rates are low, you could aim to increase them by 10% in three months.

• Experiment with Different Strategies: Once you know what needs correcting and what you want to do, you may start trying different ways. For example, if you want to improve your open rates, you may experiment with different subject lines or send times to see what works best for your audience.

• Track Results: Keep tabs on the outcomes as you try out new approaches to determine which ones perform best. Insights like these can inform future choices about your email marketing approach.

• Make Data-Driven Decisions: Decisions about your email marketing approach should be data-driven, not based on gut instinct. For example, if you find that a particular subject line or send time is driving higher open rates, you may decide to incorporate that into your regular email campaigns.

• Continuously Test and Optimize: Finally, it’s important to continuously test and optimize your email marketing strategy over time. This means regularly reviewing your metrics, setting goals for improvement, experimenting with different strategies, tracking results, and making data-driven decisions.

Summary Checklist of Action Plans

Here’s a summary checklist of action plans for leveraging email metrics for restaurant success:

• Define your email marketing goals and metrics: Identify what you want to achieve with your email campaigns and the metrics you’ll use to measure success.

• Segment your email list: Segment your email list based on customer preferences and behavior to send targeted, relevant messages.

• Personalize your email content: Use personalization to make your emails more engaging and relevant to each recipient.

• Conduct A/B testing: Test different email elements like subject lines, content, and send times to optimize performance.

• Track email performance: Track email metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates to identify what’s working and what’s not.

• Use customer feedback: You may improve your email marketing approach and your clients’ overall experience by listening to and acting on feedback from your existing clientele.

• Integrate with other marketing channels: Integrate your email marketing efforts with other marketing channels like social media and your website for a cohesive strategy.

• Stay up-to-date with industry trends: Keep up with the latest developments and standards in your field.

• Keep your email list clean: Regularly clean your email list by removing inactive subscribers and invalid email addresses to improve deliverability.

• Continuously refine your strategy: Use the insights gained from email metrics to continuously refine and improve your email marketing strategy.

Conclusion

In the food service industry, email marketing can be a potent tool. However, to truly succeed, restaurants must also be able to measure and analyze the performance of their email campaigns. Utilizing data gleaned from client emails, eateries can adjust their methods of customer interaction in order to boost sales and customer loyalty.

As Annette Franz, a customer experience strategist, says, “The real value of metrics lies not in the numbers themselves, but in the insights they provide.” By analyzing email metrics, restaurants can gain valuable insights that can lead to improved performance and greater success. With the checklist of action plans provided in this article, restaurants can take the necessary steps to leverage email metrics for success in the competitive restaurant industry.

READ ALSO: Hotel/Resort Analytics and Performance Metrics