The advertising world was sent into a frenzy this week after Clean Creatives, a watchdog campaign group for the industry, laid bare a stark contradiction. Their recent research suggests that while many advertising industry and PR firms are making loud sustainability pledges, they concurrently maintain contractual ties with fossil fuel giants. This revelation has reignited debates about the ethical responsibilities of the advertising world.
Advertising Industry Sustainability
Clean Creatives’ F-List 2023 Report meticulously details approximately 500 fossil fuel contracts stemming from 294 advertising and PR firms spanning 2022 and 2023. The magnifying glass was especially place upon prominent players such as Dentsu, Edelman, Ogilvy, Havas, Omnicom, IPG, and Publicis. These firms, the report asserts, hold significant contracts with fossil fuel titans including Shell, Geneco, Petronas, and Saudi Aramco.
The Ethical Debate: Advertising’s Responsibility in the Climate Crisis
In an era where climate change is no longer a distant specter, but a stark reality, such associations have provoked sharp criticisms. Duncan Meisel, executive director at Clean Creatives, remarked, “This is a turning point for the industry. Communication agencies working for oil and gas clients are knowingly accelerating the global climate emergency.” Meisel’s alarm bell suggests the industry’s reckoning may have just begun.
The report’s most jaw-dropping revelation zeroes in on WPP, a holding company that holds 55 fossil fuel contracts, a puzzling stance given its global net zero pledge. Close on its heels is Omnicom with 39 contracts. Ogilvy stands out among individual agencies, holding public contracts with big names such as the American Petroleum Institute, BP, and Petrobras.
Contracts with Major Oil Players
Nayantara Dutta, research director of Clean Creatives, doesn’t mince words: “Despite agencies’ net zero promises and sustainability pledges, they continue to champion the oil and gas industry.” Dutta’s remark is a clarion call for introspection within the industry, urging professionals to look beyond their immediate roles and recognize the larger picture.
However, it isn’t just about data and revelations. Clean Creatives is ensuring the message hits home—literally. Their out-of-home marketing campaign targets employees of the mentioned firms in New York City, urging them to take action. One poignant poster directly addressing Ogilvy employees reads, “Dear New Yorkers who work at Ogilvy… your employer Ogilvy is working for bullsh*tters… It’s not your fault. But you can fix it, and we can support you.”
Yet, not everyone is on the defensive. TBWA, upon being approached, clarified their client associations and emphasized their commitment to the Paris Agreement on climate change.
On the Whole…
In an age where consumers and businesses are increasingly valuing transparency, this exposé by Clean Creatives serves as both a wake-up call and an invitation for advertising agencies: to align their operations with the values they champion publicly. After all, as Olivia Macdonald, a copywriter at Cronin, notes, the ultimate goal is to make these agencies “places we can be proud to work for.”